Skip to content

April 2026: Thirlwall Inquiry final report due after Easter · CCRC still reviewing 31+ independent expert reports · Shoo Lee Panel (Feb 2025): no medical evidence of deliberate harm.

Lucy Letby Facts
Inquiry witness evidence — summary + excerpts
·Dr Nim Subhedar; Thirlwall Inquiry

Dr Nim Subhedar — external review and Thirlwall evidence

Dr Nim Subhedar, consultant neonatologist at Liverpool Women's Hospital, was one of the senior external reviewers involved in assessing the Countess of Chester neonatal cluster. His Thirlwall Inquiry evidence addresses what was known to external reviewers at the time, what additional investigations he recommended, and what happened to those recommendations.

Last updated
15 min read

Licence: Open Government Licence v3.0

Original source: thirlwall.inquiry.gov.uk

Mirrored on this site:

Crown Copyright. Mirrored under the Open Government Licence v3.0 with attribution.

Context

Dr Nim Subhedar is a consultant neonatologist at Liverpool Women’s Hospital — the regional tertiary referral centre that would normally have received babies too sick for the Countess of Chester’s Level 2 unit. He was among the senior external clinicians involved in reviewing the Countess of Chester cluster. His Thirlwall Inquiry evidence is weight-bearing because, as a practising tertiary-centre neonatologist, he was the kind of external reviewer best placed to see what the unit was actually doing wrong.

Key ground

Dr Nim Subhedar

I recommended that further specific investigations be carried out on a number of the cases. My understanding is that those recommendations were not, in all instances, acted upon.
Thirlwall Inquiry witness evidence

Read alongside

RCPCH review authors, Unit conditions evidence page.

Related on this site

Attribution and licence

Contains public-sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Original source: thirlwall.inquiry.gov.uk . Mirrored on this site on 2026-04-21.