Skip to content

April 2026: Thirlwall Inquiry final report due after Easter · CCRC still reviewing 31+ independent expert reports · Shoo Lee Panel (Feb 2025): no medical evidence of deliberate harm.

Lucy Letby Facts
New evidence

Bates v Post Office — High Court judgment on Horizon unreliability

Mr Justice Fraser's High Court judgment in Bates & Others v Post Office finds the Post Office Horizon IT system unreliable. The technical-evidence turning point in the Horizon scandal. Subsequent Court of Appeal quashings of hundreds of sub-postmaster convictions follow from December 2020 onwards. Mass statutory exoneration follows in 2024. The structural template for how collectively-resourced independent technical expertise enables appellate-level correction of mass-miscarriage convictions.

Source: Bates & Others v Post Office High Court judgment December 2019