Lucy Letby - New Final Last Ever Dewi Evans Interview

The host provides a solo commentary systematically rebutting Dewi Evans's claim, made in a post-conviction interview, that the case against Lucy Letby is now stronger than at trial. He addresses each of Evans's specific assertions in turn: that sepsis was not endemic on the unit (demonstrably false given pseudomonas and sewage contamination); that the shift rota chart is reliable (contradicted by multiple statisticians including Professor Jane Hutton); that his changing diagnosis of Child C does not undermine the conviction (it directly undermines the Court of Appeal reliance on his evidence); and that the lack of genetic testing is irrelevant (thousands of undiagnosed genetic conditions affect neonates). The commentary is particularly detailed on the swipe card data, which was reversed for nine infants and which the prosecution conceded could be bypassed at any time. Evans is characterised as repeatedly violating the Ikarian Reefer standards for expert witnesses throughout these post-conviction statements.

Last updated 2026-07-14

2 min read

Notable extracts

Short verbatim extracts from the video. Each quote is under 80 words and attributed to the speaker. Extracted under fair-dealing for review and news reporting (CDPA 1988 s.30).

Host (Speaker 1)

Evans told the court there is only one explanation for what he called astonishing blood readings. He later told Philip Hammond of Private Eye that he did not even know there was more than one way of measuring insulin until he read comments from an expert. That is not someone who should have been making definitive statements in a murder trial.

On Evans's admission of ignorance about insulin measurement methodology

Host (Speaker 1)

No genetic studies were done for any infant in this case. Yet there are between one thousand and three thousand or more unknown genetic conditions that could affect neonatal outcomes. The jury simply never heard this.

On the absence of genetic testing for any infant in the indictment

Host (Speaker 1)

The swipe card data was reversed for nine infants. Nine. And the prosecuting barrister himself conceded that anyone could follow anyone else through a door at any time without swiping. That evidence is worthless and Evans knows it.

On the unreliability of the swipe card evidence

Lucy Letby - New Final Last Ever Dewi Evans Interview

Last updated 2026-07-14

2 min read

Notable extracts

Short verbatim extracts from the video. Each quote is under 80 words and attributed to the speaker. Extracted under fair-dealing for review and news reporting (CDPA 1988 s.30).

Host (Speaker 1)

Evans told the court there is only one explanation for what he called astonishing blood readings. He later told Philip Hammond of Private Eye that he did not even know there was more than one way of measuring insulin until he read comments from an expert. That is not someone who should have been making definitive statements in a murder trial.

On Evans's admission of ignorance about insulin measurement methodology

Host (Speaker 1)

No genetic studies were done for any infant in this case. Yet there are between one thousand and three thousand or more unknown genetic conditions that could affect neonatal outcomes. The jury simply never heard this.

On the absence of genetic testing for any infant in the indictment

Host (Speaker 1)

The swipe card data was reversed for nine infants. Nine. And the prosecuting barrister himself conceded that anyone could follow anyone else through a door at any time without swiping. That evidence is worthless and Evans knows it.

On the unreliability of the swipe card evidence

Lucy Letby - New Final Last Ever Dewi Evans Interview

Notable extracts

Related on this site

Lucy Letby - New Final Last Ever Dewi Evans Interview

Notable extracts

Related on this site